Uniform Commercial Code
No one cares about the law of sales and collections until something goes wrong. When disputes arise, the parties dust off the “boilerplate” provisions printed on the back of their purchase orders and invoices. Often these provisions are in conflict with one another or do not cover the issue that actually exists. In these circumstances, where the contract involves the sale of goods, the parties must look to the provisions of the Uniform Commercial Code for answers. This Code, adopted in every State, provides a uniform body of rules for sales of goods. For sales of services, the common law of contracts applies.
The success of the Uniform Commercial Code in regulating the sale of goods has crossed over into general contract law, and many provisions of the Code have influenced the development of general contract law.
Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code covers how and when contracts for the sale of goods are formed; warranty obligations; how contracts must be performed; what happens when a party breaches a contract; and what remedies are available when a breach occurs.
Forming Contracts. Any sale of goods for a price of $500 or more must be reflected in written form. The writing must be sufficient to indicate that a contract for sale has been made by the parties and must be signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought. However, this requirement is waived in sales between merchants if one party sends a written confirmation of the contract and the other party fails to object within 10 days of receipt.
Apart from this requirement of a “writing,” the rules of contract formation are very liberal. A contract may be made in any manner sufficient to show agreement, including conduct by both parties that recognizes the existence of such a contract.
A written offer by a merchant to buy or sell goods which gives assurance that it will be held open cannot be revoked during the time stated in the offer. If no time is stated, then the offer must remain open for a reasonable period of time, but not in excess of three months.
If the customer’s purchase order contains one set of terms and conditions, and the acceptance or invoice contains another set, the additional terms of the invoice become part of the contract unless the offer limits acceptance to the terms of the offer or they materially alter it. In addition, conduct by the parties that recognizes the existence of a contract will be sufficient to establish a contract, even though the writings do not establish one. Accordingly, written exchanges and conduct must be tightly controlled to avoid inadvertent contracts.
A party may delegate performance of a contract to someone else, unless the other party has a substantial interest in having the original party perform the contract. Either party may assign its rights under a contract except where the assignment would materially impact the other party’s duties, burdens or risks.
Warranties. Unless the parties otherwise provide, the following warranties are assumed to be made by the seller as to the goods:
1. Seller has title to the goods and the right to transfer them.
2. The goods are delivered free from any security interest or other lien (other than those the buyer actually knows of).
3. The goods are “merchantable” (generally, the goods are fit for the ordinary purposes for which they are used).
4. When seller has reason to know any particular purpose for which goods are required and buyer is relying on seller’s skill or judgment to select goods, there is an implied warranty that the goods are fit for such purpose.
5. A statement of fact relating to goods creates an express warranty that the goods conform to the statement.
6. A description of the goods creates an express warranty that the goods conform to the description.
7. A sample creates an express warranty that the whole of the goods conform to the sample.
Special care must be taken to exclude or modify these warranties if they cannot be supported. Generally, the contract should contain express language that excludes warranties, or states that goods are sold “as is” or “with all faults.”
Performance. The UCC spells out how contracts are to be performed in cases where the parties have omitted the details. For example, if a buyer has paid all or part of the price of goods and the seller becomes insolvent, the buyer may recover the goods from the seller if the seller’s insolvency occurred within 10 days after receipt of the first installment of the price. Also, the buyer has the right to inspect goods at a reasonable place and time and in any reasonable manner before payment is due.
Breach of Contract. When there are defects in the goods, or a defect in their method of delivery, the buyer has the option to reject or accept all the goods or accept any portion that is acceptable and reject the rest. A notice of rejection must be delivered “seasonably,” the buyer cannot delay unreasonably. In addition, if the buyer rejects the goods while they are in his possession, he must follow the reasonable instructions of the seller with respect to the rejected goods. If no instructions are received, the buyer may store the goods for seller’s account, reship to seller or resell for seller’s account.
On the other hand, once the buyer has accepted the goods, he must pay at the contract price for any goods accepted. Acceptance occurs when the buyer after a reasonable opportunity to inspect the goods signifies to the seller that the goods are conforming, or fails or make an effective rejection (after having an opportunity to inspect). Although accepted goods may not be reshipped to the seller, buyer retains any claim based on non-conformity of the goods to warranties.
When reasonable grounds exist that make one party feel that performance by the other may be impaired, that party may demand assurances of due performance from the other party. Until he receives such assurances, he may suspend his performance. If the cost of performing the contract suddenly increases dramatically due to an event that undermines a basic assumption of the contract, the seller may delay its delivery or even fail to deliver the goods.
Remedies. When a seller discovers that buyer is insolvent, he may refuse to deliver goods except for cash, including payment for all goods previously delivered. When a buyer receives goods on credit while insolvent, the seller may reclaim the goods on demand made within ten days after the receipt.
When a buyer breaches the contract, typically by not accepting goods or failing to pay for goods already received, the seller may recover damages for non-acceptance or cancel. Damages in the case of non-acceptance of goods is the difference between the market price at the time and place of delivery and the unpaid contract price, less expenses saved as a consequence of buyer’s breach. However, if this measure of damages is inadequate to put seller in as good a position as performance would have done, then the measure of damages is the profit (including reasonable overhead) which seller would have made from full performance. Damages, in the case of non-payment, are the price of goods accepted, plus incidental damages. Alternately, when the buyer has failed to accept goods seller may resell the goods in a commercially reasonable manner and recover the difference between the resale price and the contract price, plus incidental damages. The seller does not have to account to buyer for any profit made on the resale.
When a seller breaches the contract by failing to make delivery or when the buyer rightfully rejects goods, then buyer may cancel and recover so much of the price as has been paid. In addition, the buyer may purchase goods in substitution of those due from seller and recover from seller the difference between the cost of the substituted goods and the contract price, together with incidental and consequential damages, but less expenses saved. Alternately, the buyer may recover damages for non-delivery equal to the difference between the market price at the time the buyer learned of the breach and the contract price, less expenses saved.
The measure of damages for breach of warranty is the difference between the value of the goods accepted and the value they would have had if they had been as warranted. The parties may specify liquidated damages in the agreement, but the measure must be reasonable in light of the harm caused by the breach. Unreasonably large liquidated damages are void as a penalty. Any action for breach of any contract for sale of goods must be commenced within four years after the breach occurs. The parties may shorten the period to one year (but not less).
Security Devices
Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code contains a powerful tool to aid in the collection of accounts, although many companies do not take advantage of it. It gives sellers of goods the right to retain a security interest in the goods (or other assets of the buyer) until payment. Without a security interest, the seller must take a back seat to creditors (typically banks) that do take advantage of this law.
Security Interests. A seller of goods can retain a security interest in the goods if the following procedures are adopted:
1. The buyer signs an agreement granting a security interest in the goods.
2. A financing statement is filed in the office of the Secretary of State of the state in which the buyer is located or incorporated.
The advantage of a security interest is that the secured party has a priority to the goods in the event the buyer becomes insolvent. Proceeds from any sale of the secured goods must be paid first to the seller in satisfaction of its account. A security interest in goods disappears once the goods are resold to another buyer in the ordinary course of business.
If buyer defaults in payment, a seller with a security interest in goods may take possession of the goods either by judicial process or without judicial process if it proceeds without breach of the peace. A secured party may also require the debtor to assemble the collateral and make it available to the secured party. The secured party may dispose of the collateral by public or private sale in a commercially reasonable manner. Any proceeds of such a sale must be applied first to the expenses of sale and then to the satisfaction of the debtor’s obligations. The secured party may also accept the collateral in full or partial satisfaction of the obligation under certain circumstances.
